Mawi ... yes! For some reason , My old scene started working. So I have no idea what was preventing it when I was testing it earlier. Either way, I found that when i took the two way switch out, it stopped working. So that was definitely needed in this case. However a colleague of mine is using it within a different shader and its works fine without the two way switch. He just has it as a branch of the shader that doesnt continue beyond on the pcwrite , So it must be circumstantial. Either way, thank you for your help! Beau